5 Gallon Tank Goldfish Setup: Beginner’s Guide (2025)
Published: 6 Apr 2025
You’re not alone if you’re considering adding a goldfish to a small tank. Many new fishkeepers wonder: Can a goldfish live in a 5-gallon tank? The answer might surprise you. While a 5-gallon tank may look spacious to the untrained eye, it’s unsuitable for Goldfish. Putting a goldfish in a 5-gallon tank is one of the most common beginner mistakes that often lead to poor fish health, stunted growth, and even early death.
Let’s break down why that is—and your best options.
Understanding Goldfish: Size, Growth, and Biology
Many beginner fishkeepers assume Goldfish are small, low-maintenance freshwater fish that can thrive in any tank, even a bowl or a 5-gallon tank. But Goldfish are much more complex creatures. Understanding their physical growth, biological needs, and behavior is crucial to providing a healthy and long life.
Let’s explore the three principal aspects that explain why they don’t belong in small tanks.
How Big Do Goldfish Get?
One of the biggest myths in fishkeeping is that Goldfish will “grow to the size of their tank.” In reality, Goldfish grow to their genetic potential—and only get stunted (unhealthily) when kept in cramped, stressful environments.
There are different types of Goldfish, and their sizes vary:
Common Goldfish: Can grow up to 10–12 inches long in proper conditions. They’re strong swimmers and require a lot of space.
Comet Goldfish: Similar to common Goldfish but with longer tails, often reaching 12+ inches.
Fancy Goldfish (like Orandas, Ranchus, and Fantails) typically grow 6–8 inches long and have more rounded bodies, making them slightly less active but still needing room.
In a nutshell: Even the most miniature goldfish breeds will outgrow a 5 gallon tank goldfish setup in just a few months. They need large tanks to grow appropriately without risking stunted development or illness.
Goldfish Growth Rate and Lifespan
Goldfish grow quickly during the first year and continue to grow throughout their lives. While their growth rate depends on water quality, temperature, nutrition, and tank size, Goldfish in proper environments can thrive for many years.
Average lifespan in optimal conditions: 10–15 years
Lifespan in poor tank setups (like a bowl or 5-gallon tank): 1–3 years, often with chronic health issues
Interesting fact: The oldest recorded Goldfish lived over 40 years, showing just how long-lived these fish can be with proper care.
So, if you’re thinking, “Can a goldfish live in a 5-gallon tank?” consider whether the setup will support its growth and lifespan. In nearly all cases, it won’t.
Biological Needs That Require Space
Goldfish aren’t just large fish—they’re biologically demanding in ways many underestimate.
Here’s why:
1. High Oxygen Needs
Goldfish need high oxygen levels, which are typically achieved in larger tanks with vast surface areas. In a small 5-gallon tank, oxygen can deplete quickly—especially if the water isn’t filtered or appropriately aerated.
2. Heavy Waste Producers
Goldfish have no stomachs, which means food passes through their system quickly. The result? A lot of waste. This waste breaks into ammonia, a toxic substance that can kill fish even at low concentrations.
In a small tank:
- Ammonia builds up faster than it can be broken down.
- Filtration becomes overwhelmed
- Water quality deteriorates in hours or days.
- Despite daily water changes, keeping up with the waste in a 5 gallon tank goldfish setup is nearly impossible.
3. Active Swimmers Needing Space
Despite their chubby appearance, especially in the case of fancy Goldfish, these fish are very active swimmers. In the wild, Goldfish swim long distances. In captivity, a confined tank can cause:
- Stress
- Boredom
- Aggressive or anxious behavior
- Cramped conditions also contribute to physical deformities and organ issues over time.
Summary: Why Size and Biology Matter
Putting a goldfish in a small tank is like trying to raise a puppy in a closet—there’s not enough space for their body, behavior, and biological needs. Goldfish aren’t low-effort pets. They’re hardy and intelligent but need space, oxygen, and filtration to survive and thrive.
If you’re considering a goldfish, aim for a minimum of 20 gallons for one fancy Goldfish or 40 gallons for a common goldfish. That’s the only way to ensure your Goldfish lives a long, happy life—and avoids the health problems caused by a goldfish in a 5-gallon tank.
Why a 5-gallon tank is Not Suitable for Goldfish
Limited Oxygen and Water Volume
A 5 gallon tank goldfish setup doesn’t allow enough surface area for proper oxygen exchange, making it hard for Goldfish to breathe, especially as they grow.
Poor Waste Management
Goldfish are heavy feeders and messy eaters. In a small tank, uneaten food and poop quickly break down, causing ammonia spikes. Without strong filtration and constant cleaning, water conditions quickly become unsafe.
Space Matters
Goldfish are active swimmers. A 5-gallon tank doesn’t give them room to move, explore, or stay mentally and physically healthy.
Real Story: One Reddit user tried keeping two fancy Goldfish in a 5-gallon tank. Within two weeks, both developed fin rot and had to be relocated to a larger tank for treatment.
What Happens If You Keep Goldfish in a 5-Gallon Aquarium?
Putting Goldfish in a 5-gallon tank can lead to several serious issues:
- Stunted Growth: Lack of space can stop a goldfish from growing. This doesn’t mean it’s staying healthy—it means its internal organs are still growing while its body isn’t, leading to health problems.
- Fin Rot & Disease: Small tanks often lead to poor water quality, which can cause infections and diseases like ich, fin rot, or ammonia poisoning.
- Behavioral Issues: Goldfish kept in cramped tanks may act aggressively or show signs of extreme stress (gasping, hiding, etc.).
- Shortened Lifespan: Most Goldfish in small tanks live only 1–2 years instead of their entire lifespan of 10–15 years.
Best Fish for a 5-gallon Tank Instead of Goldfish
If you already own a 5-gallon tank and are looking for fish that will thrive in it, consider these options:
Great Stocking Ideas for 5 Gallon Tank:
- Betta Fish: Colorful and low maintenance. Only one per tank.
- Shrimp (like Cherry or Amano): Great cleaners and fun to watch.
- Snails (like Nerite or Mystery): Help with algae control.
- Guppies or Endlers (3–5 max): Small, colorful, and easy to care for.
These creatures stay small and produce less waste—perfect for a small aquarium setup.
Still Want Goldfish? A Temporary Setup Plan
If you’re set on trying Goldfish in a small tank (like rescuing one or waiting on a bigger tank), here’s how to do it as safely as possible:
Best Practices for a 5-Gallon Goldfish Tank (Short-Term Only):
- Keep only one small fancy Goldfish
- Add a powerful filter (rated for 10+ gallons)
- Perform daily water changes (25–50%)
- Use water testing kits to monitor ammonia and nitrite
- Feed sparingly to reduce waste
Important: This setup is not sustainable beyond a few weeks. It’s a temporary solution, not a long-term habitat.
Recommended Tank Size for Goldfish: Expert Guidelines
Experts agree Goldfish need a lot of space.
- 1 fancy goldfish = minimum 20 gallons
- Each additional Goldfish = add 10–15 gallons
- Common/comet Goldfish = 40 gallons for one, due to size and activity
How to Upgrade from 5 Gallons to the Ideal Setup
Ready to give your Goldfish the home it deserves? Here’s how to make the move:
Budget-Friendly Upgrade Ideas:
- 20-gallon glass tank starter kits
- Pre-owned aquariums from Facebook Marketplace or Craigslist
- Plastic storage bins (yes, food-grade bins work temporarily!)
Tank Cycling Tips:
- Cycle the tank before moving the Goldfish
- Add beneficial bacteria
- Use old tank water to help kickstart the process
Myths and Misconceptions About Goldfish Tanks
It’s time to bust some myths that keep causing fishy problems:
| Goldfish grow to the size of their tank. |
|---|
False. Stunting results from poor care and a lack of natural size control. Organs continue to grow, causing internal issues. |
| Goldfish only live a couple of years. |
|---|
Wrong again. With proper care and space, Goldfish can live over a decade. |
| Goldfish are perfect for bowls and small tanks. |
|---|
Dangerously untrue. Bowls lack filters and space, like living in a closet with no bathroom. |
Studies by the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) confirm that goldfish bowls are inhumane and often lead to premature death.
Final Thoughts: What’s Best for the 5 Gallon tank goldfish
Fishkeeping should be about giving your pet the best life possible. While it might seem convenient to house a 5 gallon tank goldfish, the truth is—it’s not fair to the fish.
Goldfish are beautiful, intelligent creatures that deserve room to grow, clean water, and proper care. If you can’t upgrade to a larger tank right now, consider other fish that can thrive in smaller spaces.
FAQ for 5 Gallon Tank Goldfish
Goldfish are often sold with the impression that they can live comfortably in small tanks, but this is a misconception. A 5-gallon tank is not ideal for a goldfish in the long term. Goldfish can grow quite large; even a tiny goldfish needs space to swim freely. While a 5-gallon tank might be sufficient for a baby goldfish for a few weeks, they quickly outgrow such a small environment. For a goldfish to thrive, providing a tank of at least 20 gallons for the first goldfish is recommended, with an additional 10 gallons for each extra goldfish.
The water quality in a 5-gallon tank deteriorates quickly, which can lead to health problems like ammonia poisoning. It’s crucial to be vigilant and upgrade the tank size over time to ensure your goldfish remains healthy.
Due to its small water volume, a 5-gallon tank requires more frequent partial water changes than a larger tank. Ideally, 25-50% of the water should be changed every 1-2 weeks. If your tank is overstocked or using a less focused system, you might need to change the water more often—possibly weekly.
Regularly testing the water quality for ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates is a proactive step. Goldfish are messy eaters and produce a lot of waste, so this helps determine if the tank is experiencing any toxic buildup, necessitating more frequent water changes.
Goldfish are notorious for producing a lot of waste, so having a sound filtration system in a 5-gallon tank is crucial. Ideally, you should look for a filter rated for a tank size larger than 5 gallons to ensure it can handle the bioload. An internal or small external canister filter designed for small tanks would be a practical option.
Ensure the filter provides good mechanical, biological, and chemical filtration to keep the water clean and oxygenated. Additionally, an adjustable flow rate filter can prevent excessive water movement, which can stress the goldfish.
No, a 5-gallon tank is unsuitable for more than one goldfish, especially as they grow. As mentioned, goldfish can grow quite large, with common goldfish reaching up to 8-10 inches long and fancy goldfish around 6-8 inches. Each goldfish requires adequate swimming space, and a small tank like this will quickly lead to overcrowding, resulting in poor water quality and health issues.
If you plan to keep more than one goldfish, it’s best to provide a larger tank (at least 20 gallons for the first one and an additional 10 gallons for each one thereafter).
When decorating a 5-gallon tank for your goldfish, you should prioritize keeping the environment simple yet enriching. Avoid adding too many decorations, which can take up valuable swimming space. Opt for smooth rocks, a few live or silk plants, and small ornaments that won’t create sharp edges that could hurt your goldfish.
Ensure no items in the tank can trap debris or hinder water flow. Goldfish enjoy hiding spots, but remember that their growth and health are more important than aesthetics. Live plants are also a great choice; they help absorb waste and oxygenate the water.
Avoid decorations with small openings or intricate features that could trap your goldfish, as they tend to nibble and explore their environment.
- Be Respectful
- Stay Relevant
- Stay Positive
- True Feedback
- Encourage Discussion
- Avoid Spamming
- No Fake News
- Don't Copy-Paste
- No Personal Attacks
- Be Respectful
- Stay Relevant
- Stay Positive
- True Feedback
- Encourage Discussion
- Avoid Spamming
- No Fake News
- Don't Copy-Paste
- No Personal Attacks
